• "Toxic positivity" — LE SSERAFIM's Sakura faces backlash for live performance, sparks discussion on idol criticism

    Recently, LE SSERAFIM's Sakura found herself in the spotlight, but not for the reasons she might have hoped. During an encore performance, she was required to sing without any backing track, and her nervousness was evident.

    The scrutiny that encore stages have been receiving is believed to have contributed to Sakura's discomfort. What was once a fun interaction with fans has become another metric for the public to judge talent.

    This incident has ignited a debate among K-Pop fans about the role of criticism. Many of Sakura's fans defended her, sympathizing with her nerves and lashing out at those who criticized her. They argued that the criticism only made Sakura more fearful.

    However, others argued that criticism is a necessary part of being an idol. After all, being an idol is not just a passion project, it's a job. And like any job, if you don't meet expectations, you may face criticism.

    Criticism, when it's constructive and not malicious, isn't a form of hate. It can help identify areas for improvement.

    In Sakura's case, some felt that despite her years in the industry, she hadn't shown significant improvement. While some fans argue that her time in AKB48 didn't include formal training, others believe that shouldn't excuse her lack of progress.

    The trend of overprotecting idols has become more prevalent with newer generations. As K-Pop's popularity grows and its fanbase expands internationally, many fans have become fiercely defensive of their idols, attacking anyone who disagrees. Some believe this has led to a less vibrant industry.

    This overprotectiveness, or "toxic positivity" as one netizen called it, can stifle growth in the industry and among idols. The challenge arises when fans blur the line between the idol as a performer and as a person.

    Yes, idols are human beings offstage, but onstage, they're part of an industry where they have a job to do. Part of that job involves becoming a "product" of their company.

    As much as fans might not like to hear it, the industry is consumer-driven, and idols are there to deliver. Sometimes, it's the fans who struggle to differentiate between "the idol" and "the person."

    Here are some comments from netizens:

    "Encore stages were never about how good you sing live. That's what the actual stages are for. Kpop fans have ruined something that used to be just artists having fun with their fans."

    "Sakura looked like she was about to cry on that encore stage. The bullying she has received is truly evil. It's heartbreaking to see her scared on stage because she knows people will criticize her. Kpop fans can be absolutely disgusting."

    "Being an idol is a job. She chose that path so she should find ways to excel. Just like a normal employee, you get criticized and receive feedback if you're not doing well, and worst-case scenario, you get fired. We shouldn't normalize being okay with minimal improvements."

    "Criticism isn't hate. Sakura has been in the industry for 12 years, which is only three years less than Taemin. If Taemin went from a poor singer to being comparable to main vocalists, what's stopping her?!"

    "The reason Kpop is so stagnant right now is because of people like you. You all can't criticize idols who are underperforming."

    What are your thoughts?

    Source[1]

  • Lee Jong Suk Shocked after Hearing What’s Happening to NewJeans - Fans Can’t Believe his Reaction to their Legal Battle

    The legal fight between NewJeans and ADOR has officially begun, and actor Lee Jong Suk’s reaction is grabbing attention.

    On April 3, the Seoul Central District Court held the first trial for ADOR’s lawsuit against NewJeans, aiming to confirm the validity of their exclusive contracts. This follows the court’s previous decision on March 21, which sided with ADOR and blocked the members from carrying out entertainment activities.

    NewJeans previously argued for contract termination based on 11 reasons, including issues with Min Hee Jin’s removal as ADOR’s CEO, claims that HYBE undervalued their success, and even allegations that HYBE considered “ruining” their brand.

    However, the court dismissed all of these claims. In response, the members expressed their frustration through international media, calling the ruling “shocking” and saying, “It seems like South Korea wants to turn us into revolutionaries.”

    While fans remain divided, Lee Jong Suk’s reaction has sparked a huge discussion. The actor, known for his calm and reserved personality, was reportedly taken aback by the situation. “This is crazy… What is even happening?” he allegedly said after hearing about the legal battle. His shocked response quickly spread online, with fans agreeing that the situation is beyond belief.

    With NewJeans suspending their activities and ADOR holding the upper hand in court, all eyes are now on how this legal fight will unfold.

    The next steps will determine whether NewJeans can overturn the decision or if ADOR will maintain full control over their careers.

    Source (1)